mspinky.com

[saad]

hey all

With certain MP3's, Maxi patch refuses to play them. I get the bang message, and in the log window, it just keeps scrolling and saying "too much recursion, line 455".

Its not applicable to any type of MP3. Its not a certain bitrate, or source, or anything. There is no artwork. If i convert it to wav, it works, but I dont have the disc space or time to do that.

So any ideas?

[dlpinkstah]

What I do with mp3's that Maxi-Patch won't handle is to transcode them into a new mp3 using iTunes. Generally speaking, all mp3 created using iTunes should work with Maxi-Patch. To transcode into new mp3, just load in all the mp3 that Maxi-Patch can't play into a special playlist inside iTunes. Then, select all the bad mp3 and choose from the "Advanced" pull-down menu the option "Convert Selection to MP3". It should then do them all at once for you.

[taggalucci]

At the moment, about 30% of some of my recent mp3s won't play with the same "bang" shown in the song name text box.

I have tried what dlpinkstah suggests i.e. creating a playlist in iTunes and converting the selection to mp3. But still, not one of these will play.

I would like to better understand why it is challenging for Maxi Patch to play these when they will play fine in every other media player.

Out of interest, converting them to a mov in Quicktime will allow these to play, but that's not ideal.

[dlpinkstah]

please email me one of the problem mp3's that won't play so I can figure out why.... or post one somewhere I can download it. All my mp3's work fine with the program.

[dlpinkstah]

Please also remove album artwork from all mp3's that you want to load into Maxi-Patch. Eventually I'll have a fix so that we can reliably read mp3's with the inserted artwork, but for now you'll need to get rid of that in order to reliably load mp3's into the program.

[taggalucci]

Hi

Thanks for the swift reply.

Removing the artwork solved the issue for all the files I have tried so far.

Thanks again

[dlpinkstah]

Well I'm glad to hear that. I apologize if you were especially attached to the album artwork. Perhaps in an upcoming version we can find a way to extract the pictures and mix them with video...

[kbooms1w]

Just to add to the list of problematic mp3s, I was converting some files tonight and found that encoding them at 48 khz (which I wasn't even trying to do), instead of 44.1 khz gave Pinky VST fits, very garbled, terrible reading of the waveform.

Encoded them at 44.1 khz and no problems, even at 320 kpbs.

[djpash]

I'm having similar issues with maxipatchAO, I've tried removing the album artwork...didn't work. Going to try and batch re-encode them...

I really hope this resolves the issue...almost half of my collection isn't loading up

[dlpinkstah]

It would really help if you can email to me, or put someplace on a server for download, some of these mp3's that are problematic. As I said previously, all of my current collection is loading and playing fine for me. If I don't have some of the ones that won't load then I can't fix the problem.

[honeo]

it could not be so hard to "ignore" the header of the mp3 while reading the file, don't konw if your only using max for te app. but with c or c++ it's not so difficult to read the header an just loading the audio into a buffer, would be great if trhe artwork could be extracted

[djpash]

[djpash]

[dlpinkstah]

You must be using the Winblows PC version. Both of these files load and play perfectly on the mac OSX version just as they are. I guess this means I have some more debugging to do on the PC version. However, even on the PC I just found that re-encoding as MP3 using iTunes creates a new MP3 that loads and plays just fine. So is there a reason you won't use iTunes to re-encode your MP3 that won't work? iTunes is a free, and very easy-to-use program. It should be a very easy way to work around this bug (temporarily) until I can (hopefully) fix it for you Windoze people.

In the future, when you post a bug report, please be sure to provide a full description of your system.

[dlpinkstah]

I should also point out that both of these files will load and play perfectly in Pinky VST, both OSX and Winblows. So the bug is apparently in my Max/MSP interface code. Should be able to fix pretty easily.